Silence isn’t safe, neither is noise - Communication in the Age of Exposure #NewRulesApply

Our world view is ever more shaped by data, agents and algorithms, but people are still the ultimate recipients of corporate messaging. So, in some sense nothing has changed, and yet so much has. The end goal remains the same; it’s about saying the right things, at the right time, to the right people, but there’s an interesting (and infuriating) tension at play.
On the one hand, these “right people” that you’re trying to reach are now spread across more channels, and there’s increased pressure for leaders to be active online. Hawthorn’s own research confirmed something we’ve seen in practice – that there’s an expectation on leaders to build a personal brand which extends beyond the business, and an expectation for them to do this using their own channels rather than relying on the media. 58 per cent say that a CEO who relies mainly on traditional media to build credibility now risks appearing behind the curve.
But that said, communicating more and often comes with consequences. The very channels which offer you opportunities for storytelling and narrative control can work against you. Something you said ten years ago can be kept in the public domain by an LLM. Your LinkedIn post can become a magnet for hostile comments. There’s a consensus that engaging critics online only makes things worse – 61 per cent of our survey respondents agree.
If you are a leader of a business in the public eye, retreating from it all isn’t the answer either. In our experience, silence can have a worse outcome, because the void invites speculation. This speculation can come from anywhere; responsible journalists at a respectable title if you’re lucky, rabble-rousing Redditors if you’re not. Being prepared and proactively building a presence always beats developing a profile in reaction to audience engagement; and doing so strategically and authentically.
The ‘strategy’ part of this comes from the unglamourous task of investing in research and truly understanding your audience. Three quarters of the leaders we surveyed say their teams experience tension or delay between moving fast enough to fill a narrative vacuum and exercising rigorous due diligence. The tension or delay only comes if you’re unprepared. Leaders who are already in touch with their consumers, communities and stakeholders, and what they stand for, aren’t choosing between speed or judgement, or channel for that matter. They’ve done the thinking in advance.
Authenticity comes from listening to all the best practice advice out there and tailoring it to suit your personality, business and judgment. Proactively building a presence doesn’t require you to be everywhere, all at once. It requires you to regularly think about and reevaluate what you want to be known for, and by whom. Having conviction is the answer to that one question, and the channel decisions make themselves.
The Age of Exposure is the first report in Hawthorn's New Rules Apply campaign. The premise is that the rules of communications are being rewritten, by everything from the end of two-party politics to geopolitical disruption and the polarisation of the ESG agenda.






























