Skip to main content
← Insights

Pleasing all of the people all of the time? Taking a position on sustainability issues in a time of growing polarisation

18 November 2026 Salonee Gadgil-Wilson

Jamie Plotnek, Senior Director, Head of Sustainability 

Not so long ago, it was commonplace for senior executives to make bold public pronouncements on matters of environmental and social sustainability – the era of Davos do-goodery. More recently there has been a notable quietening of voices, as these issues have become ever more polarised, politicised and on occasion weaponised.  

The temperature has changed. The situation has become more febrile. But as people get further apart, should leaders seek to bridge the divide, pick a side, or just keep quiet? 

In the short term, there is a strong case for staying on the sidelines. When considering public engagement with critics, just 17 percent of respondents to Hawthorn’s survey believe this is more likely to make the situation better than worse. And over half believe that compared to five years ago, a single misjudged public comment or internal leak is now more likely to cause permanent career damage. 

In our conversations with senior leaders, we heard recurring references to the chilling effect from operating in an information ecosystem where words can be easily recalled, but context is easily forgotten.  

Most businesses have not been directly subjected to sustainability-related campaigns from activist investors, employee petitions, shareholder resolutions, or legal challenges from NGOs and Attorneys General. Yet the reverberations from high profile examples of peers under pressure still echo through the corridors of power, influencing decision-making. 

The underlying issues are not going anywhere. In most cases, they are becoming more severe. Climate risks are now climate realities. Ecosystem decline is pushing up costs and reducing productivity. Inequality is rising, professions are becoming precarious, and social license to operate is under serious pressure.  

The consequence is that while companies often continue to press ahead with sustainability strategies, there is an emerging vacuum of sustainability leadership. The weight of evidence shows that despite the appeal of the rhyme, if you go woke you really don’t go broke. But the turbulence from any sort of backlash makes day-to-day management far harder. 

There is no right or wrong answer for how executives should respond to this challenge, as circumstances can differ significantly between organisations. For most business leaders caution is advisable, but it is imperative both strategically and ethically to engage with the issues and take a position. 

Reputation in The Age of Exposure - Full Report